Less natural births in private hospitals

12:0AM, Sep 13th 2012

Australian women giving birth in private hospitals are 20 percent more likely to undergo medical interventions such as caesareans than mums who give birth in public hospitals.

Image: Getty

Australian women giving birth in private hospitals are 20 percent more likely to undergo medical interventions than mums who go to public hospitals.

A newly released study of nearly 700,000 NSW women with low-risk pregnancies has found that while 35 percent in public hospitals had natural vaginal births with no medical intervention, this figure dropped to 15 percent for women choosing a private hospital.

And this is a phenomenon that has increased dramatically in the past decade, according to study leader Dr Hannah Dahlen, a professor of midwifery at the University of Western Sydney.

To challenge the popular belief that women receiving interventions such as caesareans and induced labour are older or less healthy, Dr Dahlen said they specifically sought out women aged 20 to 34 with a low risk of birth complications.

With one in three babies now delivered by caesarean section in Australia, rising public health concerns over the associated risks to mother and child has led the New South Wales government to implement policy aiming to increase vaginal birth rates.

Related: Caesareans not always best for baby

Researchers noted that the cost to the taxpayer of rising interventions is also significant, with birth costs increasing by up to 50 percent once interventions were introduced among first-time low-risk mothers.

“The fact that these procedures, which were initially life saving, are now so commonplace and do not appear to be associated with improved [baby] death rates demands close review,” found the study, published this week in the British Medical Journal’s BJM Open online journal.

The marked difference in birthing experiences of women in public and private care is “potentially due to variations in the practitioners’ behaviour rather than the health of women,” concludes the study.

“The findings suggest that a two-tier system exists in Australia, without any obvious benefit for women and babies, and a level of medical over servicing which is difficult to defend.”

But the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians has expressed concern over the study’s findings. In a statement posted on the College’s website, president Dr Rupert Sherwood denied the notion that “low-risk women were routinely being given unnecessary obstetric care.”

Dr Sherwood called the study “an open criticism of those women who make the choice to access…one-on-one continuity of care with a specialist medical practitioner.”

He asserted that women receiving obstetric interventions were well informed about the implications. “In particular, the private hospital patient is more likely than most to have carefully researched her options prior to making choices about care,” said Dr Sherwood

“It is important that we respect the choices women make and continue our strong advocacy for the best care to be available to all women, whatever their choice of birth provider or location.”

What was your birthing experience in public or private care? Did you have any medical interventions? Share your thoughts below.

comments powered by Disqus

Related articles

 
 
instagram
  • Look who has arrived??!!!! Our editor, Fiona, had her BEAUTIFUL bay boy last night!!! We are all like kids at Christmas in the office today!!! Soooo much excitement!! Welcome to our family, Jacob! Xxx  #babyboy #onedayold #greathair #cutestbaby

    mother and baby Look who has arrived??!!!! Our editor, Fiona, had her BEAUTIFUL bay boy last night!!! We are all like kids at Christmas in the office today!!! Soooo much excitement!! Welcome to our family, Jacob! Xxx #babyboy #onedayold #greathair #cutestbaby

    More from the team
  • Rumour has is that Lara Bingle and Sam Worthington are having a baby!! What beautiful news for them. Sources say she is in the early weeks so not 100% confirmed yet!! #welovebabynews #hopeitstrue

    mother and baby Rumour has is that Lara Bingle and Sam Worthington are having a baby!! What beautiful news for them. Sources say she is in the early weeks so not 100% confirmed yet!! #welovebabynews #hopeitstrue

    More from the team
  • Spring has sprung! Looking forward to the really cute offerings from @seedheritage for the little ones!

    mother and baby Spring has sprung! Looking forward to the really cute offerings from @seedheritage for the little ones!

    More from the team
  • Regram @sodacommunications 
We were treated to a yummy morning tea while checking out the new #LorraineLea linen and kids ranges!

    mother and baby Regram @sodacommunications We were treated to a yummy morning tea while checking out the new #LorraineLea linen and kids ranges!

    More from the team
  • Can't wait to try out the new #bioelixia stretch mark cream!

    mother and baby Can't wait to try out the new #bioelixia stretch mark cream!

    More from the team
  • Apparently Eva Mendes and Ryan Gosling have had their baby??!! Beyond excited to learn if it's a boy or girl!!! This will have to be one genetically blessed child! Is your money on a boy or girl?! #evamendes #ryangosling #babynews #soexcited

    mother and baby Apparently Eva Mendes and Ryan Gosling have had their baby??!! Beyond excited to learn if it's a boy or girl!!! This will have to be one genetically blessed child! Is your money on a boy or girl?! #evamendes #ryangosling #babynews #soexcited

    More from the team
  • GIVEAWAY TIME!!! Neutrogena has you covered this spring/summer with beautiful, effective sunscreens for the whole family. For your chance to win an AWESOME Neutrogena pack that contains 2 x Wet Skin Sunscreen Sprays, 1 x Ultra Sheer Clear Face Sunscreen, 1 x Beach Defence Sunscreen Lotion, 1 x Ultrasheer Body Mist Sunscreen Spray and 1 x Ultra Sheer Dry Touch sunscreen lotion follow @motherbaby_au and repost this image and #neutrogenaau The lucky winner of this pack, valued at over $100, will be notified on Friday morning! Good luck!! #motherandbabyaucompetition #slipslopslap #sunsafety

    mother and baby GIVEAWAY TIME!!! Neutrogena has you covered this spring/summer with beautiful, effective sunscreens for the whole family. For your chance to win an AWESOME Neutrogena pack that contains 2 x Wet Skin Sunscreen Sprays, 1 x Ultra Sheer Clear Face Sunscreen, 1 x Beach Defence Sunscreen Lotion, 1 x Ultrasheer Body Mist Sunscreen Spray and 1 x Ultra Sheer Dry Touch sunscreen lotion follow @motherbaby_au and repost this image and #neutrogenaau The lucky winner of this pack, valued at over $100, will be notified on Friday morning! Good luck!! #motherandbabyaucompetition #slipslopslap #sunsafety

    More from the team
  • We love the #Urbo2 pram... And so do Kim Kardashian and Kanye West by the looks of it! Good choice guys, good choice! #mamasandpapas #pram #coolestcouple #kimkardashian @kimkardashian #kanyewest #adelaide

    mother and baby We love the #Urbo2 pram... And so do Kim Kardashian and Kanye West by the looks of it! Good choice guys, good choice! #mamasandpapas #pram #coolestcouple #kimkardashian @kimkardashian #kanyewest #adelaide

    More from the team
  • This new cot linen from @kipandco is rocking our world!! They have collaborated with @munsterkids for one ahhh-maaaa-zinnggg collection. If you want something bold and bright that is going to make a statement, then check this out TODAY!! Got a feeling this will sell out fast! #musthave #kipandco #munsterkids #alsodokidsbedlinen #socool

    mother and baby This new cot linen from @kipandco is rocking our world!! They have collaborated with @munsterkids for one ahhh-maaaa-zinnggg collection. If you want something bold and bright that is going to make a statement, then check this out TODAY!! Got a feeling this will sell out fast! #musthave #kipandco #munsterkids #alsodokidsbedlinen #socool

    More from the team
  • Start Young and Stay With It!!! At just a few months of age, an infant can look at pictures, listen to your voice, and point to objects. Guide your little one by pointing to the pictures, and say the names of the various objects. By drawing attention to pictures and associating words with both pictures and real-world objects, your child will learn the importance of language!! And you will have a laugh at some of the things they come out with!!! What's your favourite book to read with the kids?

    mother and baby Start Young and Stay With It!!! At just a few months of age, an infant can look at pictures, listen to your voice, and point to objects. Guide your little one by pointing to the pictures, and say the names of the various objects. By drawing attention to pictures and associating words with both pictures and real-world objects, your child will learn the importance of language!! And you will have a laugh at some of the things they come out with!!! What's your favourite book to read with the kids?

    More from the team